Skip to main content

2026 Week 3: What this story means to me #52Ancestorsin52Weeks

So .... in the future one of your descendants wants to delve into their family history. Let's imagine they are really good at tracing records such as birth, marriage, deaths and censuses. They find you - but what do they really know about you, apart from those crucial dates, places and your job? (Of course, we don't know how far your imprint on today's social media will transfer through the generations, so they might very well find out what you had for lunch and where yesterday, but we don't know that for certain.) There may well be some older relative who remembers you and you may get lucky if they knew you well enough to tell them what kind of a person you were and some stories about you. But most people will likely remain unknown, existing as a name and relevant dates. That's quite sad really, as everyone has their story to tell.

A story that I have been luckily enough to piece together, and, which I have written about before, is that of my 3 x great granduncle, James McAra. James is important to me as he killed his brother, my 3 x great grandfather, Alexander McAra, by striking him with an iron bar in an argument in the iron mill where they both worked. For this deed, James was sentenced in 1811 to deportation to Van Diemens Land in Tasmania. 

James' story could have ended there for me.  But it didn't. He could have been written off as a "bad person" and forgotten about, while I pursued other genealogical puzzles. But having read the High Court Trial transcripts and the witness statements, it became clear that James had acted out of character, that if anyone was the 'bad person' it was the victim, and that James had been driven to lose the temper by his brother's behaviour over the long term. That was probably why he wasn't hanged for his crime. In any case, James was destined to die in Tasmania and never return to Scotland. 

Now, James McAra has two gravestones. On the one in Cramond Kirkyard, his year of death is given as around the date of his transportation. On the other, in Port Sorell, Tasmania, his death is recorded as being in 1840,  almost 30 years since his deportation. The inscription on the Scottish stone is the bare minimum and obviously wrong, being inscribed much later by family, who may have been totally unaware of the family tragedy. However, the Tasmanian stone does tell a story:

Gravestone of James McAra in Port Sorell. Source: Ancestry.com

That inscription gives insight into the life he must have led there and that means a lot more to me, than names, important events and dates. The inscription on the stone plus other official documentation I have found bear witness to James' character. He was pardoned by the Governor in 1836 and given land in 1839, land which he bequeathed to the daughters of a friend. He was also friends with the chief constable and gaoler and had saved his life! James may have left Scotland as a criminal, but he seems to have made the most of his life as a deportee and been liked in his community.

James could have been forgotten after his deportation, but I am glad he hasn't been. It's good to have been able to get a small look into the man he was.

To learn more about James: 

Crime and punishment

In Tasmania

Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

2025 Week 26 : Favourite name #52Ancestorsin52Weeks

 As well as researching my own family, one of the other trees I have spent a lot of time on is that of my daughter-in-law, Lucy. Whereas my heritage is Scots and Irish, Lucy's is English and therefore some of the names I came across were quite different to those found in my own tree. One of my first favourites was a Francis Badger who appeared in the 1851 census for England! He wasn't actually a relative, but an apprentice to Lucy's 3 x great grandfather and who also lodged with the family.  I did wonder how that  surname came about - did the original Badger have  a funnily shaped face? or perhaps a white streak through his hair?? Or was he just an annoying person?? I'll never know, but it was fun to find him! Francis Badger's entry at the bottom in the 1851 census for England. Source: Ancestry.co.uk However, my all time favourite name - and character - from Lucy's tree is a man named Golden Bridge ! He is Lucy's 5x great grandfather and he was born in Essex...
Post a Comment
Read more

2025 Week 12: Historic Event #52Ancestorsin52Weeks

The Battle of Arbroath, one of Scotland's bloodiest battles, was fought in the summer of 1345 between rival claimants to the post of Baillie of the Regality. The Baillie of the Regality chosen by the monks of Arbroath Abbey at that time was Alexander Lindsay. This post gave Lindsay power and prestige and he was responsible for upholding the law in the lands around the abbey. However, like many men in positions of authority both past and present, he chose to abuse his position of power and his fighting men caused mayhem within the walls of the Abbey. This led to the monks deciding to replace Lindsay with Alexander Ogilvy, who had hereditary claims to the position, but who unfortunately was Lindsay's enemy ... and my 15 x great-uncle! His sister, Isobel had married into Clan Oliphant and, on paper at least, Isobel is my 15 x great grandmother! Of course, the appointment of Ogilvy was not acceptable to Lindsay, who then raised an army of 1000 men and marched to Arbroath Abbey to r...
1 comment
Read more

2024 Week 19: Preserve #52Ancestorsin52Weeks

 A few years ago, I came into the possession of a family bible. It was the family bible of my paternal grandparents, John McAra and Christina Walker. Until her death in 2018, the bible had been in the hands of my Aunt Inez, widow of my Uncle Will McAra. When I started enquiring as to its whereabouts, I found that it was her grandson, John, who now had it. John himself had no real interest in it at all, so he was quite happy to hand it over to me. However, it was, to say the least, in a bit of a state. The front cover was completely detached and there were many loose pages as the spine of the book was also damaged and detached. I had no choice but to take it to a book repairer in Glasgow, where it was repaired as best it could be. The bible itself had been originally published in Glasgow in the late 19th century. In Victorian times it was common for Christian families to have such a large bible in which they could record events such as births, marriages and deaths. The one I have al...
1 comment
Read more